CHOW BRIGHT VENTURES HOLDINGS PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: CHOW🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors recognizes the importance of a sound internal control system. It realizes that it has a key duty to ensure the Company has in place an appropriate and adequate internal control system in order to operate its business as targeted with efficiency, optimization of resources, maintenance of assets, prevention or reduction of deficiencies, control of any possible damage, accurate and reliable accounting and financial reporting, and compliance with laws, rules and regulations relevant to its business operation.


The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to take charge of reviewing the appropriateness and effectiveness of the Company's internal control systems to ensure they are appropriate, adequate, and compliant with internal control principles of the Committee of Sponsoring Organization of the Treadway Commission (“COSO”) encompassing management control, operational control, accounting and finance control, and compliance control.


At the Board meeting no. 1/2024 on 28 February 2024, the Board of Directors, including directors who are independent directors and Audit Committee members, considered and assessed the adequacy of the Company’s internal control system by enquiring with management and work units involved as well as Internal Audit Department of the Company with reference to the Internal Control Adequacy Evaluation Form of the Office of the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) covering the following five perspectives:

1. Control environment

2. Risk assessment

3. Control activities

4. Information and communication

5. Monitoring activities


The Board is of the opinion that the Company has sufficient internal controls that are suitable for its business operation with personnel available to efficiently undertake control activities and monitoring of business operation of subsidiaries so as to prevent seeking gains or benefits from the Company’s assets. Details of the assessment of the adequacy of its internal control system are presented as follows:

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

The Company has established an internal control policy and risk management framework, as well as set up an internal audit department under the supervision of the Audit Committee. The internal audit department's role is to assess the management and operational efficiency of the Company, with support and reporting to the Audit Committee, which is delegated by the Board of Directors to evaluate the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system, as well as the risk management systems of the organization. This ensures the effectiveness of the Company's internal control system, following practices from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) of Thailand and the COSO internal control framework. Additionally, the Audit Committee reviews the internal audit results for key business processes every quarter, along with identifying issues and providing recommendations to management.


The Audit Committee is part of the Board of Directors, promoting an environment of control and audit, both internally and externally, independent of management. It also leverages knowledge and experience to ask relevant and in-depth questions about management's work and follows up on responses with regular analysis. The Committee ensures that the financial, accounting, internal audit, and auditing departments have adequate time to perform their duties and meet with management. Furthermore, it ensures that the information provided to the Board is adequate and up-to-date.4o mini

COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM)

The Company has adopted COSO – ERM 2017 (Enterprise Risk Management – Integrating with Strategy and Performance), which categorizes the elements of the risk management process into five components:


1. Governance and Culture

2. Strategy & Objective Setting

3. Performance

4. Review & Revision, and

5. Information, Communication & Reporting


The Company believes that enterprise risk management is a process that helps achieve organizational objectives, manage risks within acceptable levels, and reduce potential obstacles or unexpected events that may affect profitability, operations, and the trust of shareholders and other stakeholders. It aims to protect the Company’s resources, respond effectively to changes in the business environment, establish good management and control systems, build confidence, create added value for the Company, and ensure stable and sustainable growth.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

the Company has established an internal audit unit to report directly to the Audit Committee to support the monitoring and supervision task of internal audit performance with Mr.Thanaphat Phimphahuappointed as Vice President Internal Audit. Mr.Thanaphat Phimphahu, He possesses the necessary knowledge and capability, appropriate qualifications, experience in internal auditing, understanding of the Company’s business, and ability to effectively monitor and assess the internal control system. The Internal Audit Supervisor’s profile is as shown in Attachment 3.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The appointment, removal, transfer, or termination of the head of the internal audit department must be reviewed and approved by the Audit Committee as stipulated in the Audit Committee Charter.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Chow Energy Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonInvestment in and consulting on investment in renewable power generation and distribution business

related by common directors

2024-12-31T00:00
Shining Sky Holdings Company Limited Juristic PersonConsulting on investment in renewable power generation and distribution businesses and provision of services for design, installation and maintenance of power generation system

related by common directors

2024-12-31T00:00
Chow International Company LimitedJuristic PersonInvestment in and consulting on investment in renewable power generating and distribution businesses and the Group's business center

There are shareholders and/or directors of the group of companies

2024-12-31T00:00
Premier Solution Company LimitedJuristic PersonConsulting on investment in renewable power generation and distribution businesses and provision of services for design, installation and maintenance of power generation system

There are shareholders and/or directors of the group of companies

2024-12-31T00:00
Shining Solutions Company LimitedJuristic PersonConsulting on investment in renewable power generation and distribution businesses and provision of services for design, installation and maintenance of power generation system

related by common directors

2024-12-31T00:00
Chow and CKE Renewable Company LimitedJuristic PersonSale of renewable energy generation systems

There are shareholders and/or directors of the company group

2024-12-31T00:00
Captain Cash Holding Company LimitedJuristic PersonInvestment in Personal loan and Nano finance under supervison

related by common directors

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
5.37 · Necessity: The Company provides business administration services. These services are conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price by agreement · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Management Fee Income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or potential conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.0 · Necessity: The Company provided loans for investment in renewable energy power plant projects and working capital for business operations. These transactions were conducted under normal business terms and conditions and criteria agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities. · Description: Pricing Policy: Rate 2.04-4.24% · As of yesteryear: 6.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest Received · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.0 · 166.0 · Necessity: In 2023, the Company received dividends from its subsidiaries totaling THB 166 million. The Company received intercompany dividends in accordance with the declared dividend payments. These transactions were conducted on an arm's length basis and in line with the terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related parties, consistent with normal business practices. · Description: Pricing Policy: Published Rate · As of yesteryear: 166.0 · Nature of transaction: Dividend · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 18.0 · Necessity: The Company has a policy of providing intercompany loans to and from subsidiaries for the purpose of working capital. These transactions are conducted in accordance with arm's length principles and criteria agreed upon between the companies within the group and related parties, as is customary in business. · Description: Pricing Policy: Interest rate 0.55-6.58% per annum · As of yesteryear: 6.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest Paid · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are normal business transactions and do not provide any benefit to related parties or potential conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 2.0 · Necessity: The Company paid for office space rental. The aforementioned transactions were conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Contractual Rate · As of yesteryear: 2.26 · Nature of transaction: Rental fee · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or potential conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.0 · 2.61 · Necessity: Chow Energy collects office space rental fees from its affiliated companies. These transactions are conducted under normal commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, consistent with standard business practices. · Description: Pricing Policy: Contractual Rate · As of yesteryear: 1.96 · Nature of transaction: Rental income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 678.57 · Necessity: Short-term loans between the Company with its subsidiaries for working capital purposes, with promissory notes issued, bearing interest rates of 1.40-6.58%, unsecured, and payable on demand. · Description: The aforementioned list pertains to the provision or receipt of financial assistance deemed reasonable and subject to a fixed interest rate as stipulated in the agreement. · As of yesteryear: 1031.7 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
12.07 · Necessity: The Company provides business administration services. These services are conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price by agreement · As of yesteryear: 28.2 · Nature of transaction: Management Fee Income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 16.0
1.35 · Necessity: The Company provides business management services. These services are conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price by agreement · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Management Fee Income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
457.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries generates revenue from providing EPC contracting services to affiliated companies. These business transactions are conducted under normal business practices and adhere to the agreed-upon commercial terms and criteria between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price on agreement · As of yesteryear: 191.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from installation services · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 88.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries generates revenue from the sale of solar cell equipment to affiliated companies. These transactions are conducted in accordance with the agreed-upon commercial terms and criteria between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as per standard business practices. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price by agreement · As of yesteryear: 45.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from equipment sales · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are normal business transactions and do not provide any benefit to related parties or any potential conflicts of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 12.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries generates revenue from asset maintenance and management services provided to affiliated companies. These business transactions are conducted under normal business practices and adhere to the agreed-upon commercial terms and criteria established between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price by agreement · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from Asset Management and Administration · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 12.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries earns interest income from loans extended to affiliated joint venture companies for investments in renewable energy power plant projects and for use as working capital. These transactions are conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary in business. · Description: Pricing Policy: Interest rate of 4.99-6.03% per year · As of yesteryear: 2.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest Received · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 14.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries provides business management services. These services are conducted in accordance with commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price on application · As of yesteryear: 4.0 · Nature of transaction: Management Fee Income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 8.0 · Necessity: Its subsidiaries employs skilled personnel in electrical engineering, project management, and the operation and maintenance (O&M) of renewable energy power plants. These power plants are constructed and serviced for clients by a group of affiliated companies. These business transactions adhere to commercial terms and criteria agreed upon by the companies within the group and the individuals or entities involved, as is customary business practice. · Description: Pricing Policy: Price on application · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Labor costs for installation contractors · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
5.0 · Necessity: Chow Energy collects office space rental fees from a group of affiliated companies. These business transactions are conducted under normal commercial terms and conditions agreed upon between the companies within the group and related individuals or entities. This practice aligns with standard business practices. · Description: Pricing Policy: Rate as per Lease Agreement · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Rental income · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
9.5 · Necessity: Short-term loan between the Company and its affiliates and joint ventures for working capital purposes, with promissory notes issued at an interest rate of 0.25%, unsecured, and payable on demand. · Description: The aforementioned list pertains to the provision or receipt of financial assistance deemed reasonable and subject to a fixed interest rate as stipulated in the agreement. · As of yesteryear: 9.5 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are regular business transactions and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
40.19 · Necessity: Short-term loans between the Company and its affiliates and joint ventures for working capital purposes, with promissory notes issued, bearing interest rates of 0.45-0.55%, unsecured, and payable on demand. · Description: The aforementioned list pertains to the provision or receipt of financial assistance deemed reasonable and bearing a fixed interest rate as stipulated in the agreement. · As of yesteryear: 40.19 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are customary to the business and do not provide any benefit to related parties or those who may have a conflict of interest. · As of year before yesteryear: 40.19

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Company shall establish procedures for the approval of transactions between the Company and its affiliates in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Market for Alternative Investment, whereby the Board of Directors or any person who may have a conflict of interest, may benefit, or may have any conflict of interest with the Company shall not be entitled to vote on the approval of such transactions.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

The Company's policy on inter-group transactions can be classified by transaction type as follows:


• Ordinary course of business transactions and transactions supporting the ordinary course of business with general commercial terms and conditions. such as the purchase or sale of goods and services. The Company has established a policy for inter-group transactions to have various terms and conditions in accordance with the nature of normal business practices at market prices, which are comparable to prices charged to unrelated parties. The Company shall comply strictly with the agreed upon contracts and shall specify the prices and conditions of the transactions clearly, fairly, and in a manner that does not result in the transfer of benefits. The Internal Audit Department will be responsible for reviewing the information and preparing a report for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the appropriateness of the prices and the reasonableness of the transactions on a quarterly basis.

• Ordinary course of business transactions and transactions supporting the ordinary course of business without special terms and conditions, and other inter-group transactions excluding the acquisition or disposal of assets and the receipt or provision of financial assistance, such as loans, guarantees, and the use of assets as collateral. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasonableness and necessity of transactions before they are executed. The transactions must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the requirements for disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of major assets of the Company or its subsidiaries (if any). The Board of Directors shall not have the right to vote to approve any transaction in which they or any person who may have a conflict of interest have any interest. The Board of Directors must also disclose the nature of the relationship and details of such transactions to the Board of Directors for consideration. In addition, if the Audit Committee does not have the expertise to consider such inter-group transactions, the Company will have an independent expert provide an opinion on such inter-group transactions for use in the decision-making of the Board of Directors or shareholders, as the case may be.

Contents